Kelly, We have tried Gamefly before and Andrew enjoyed it for the most part. He really liked being able to try the games and send them back if he didnt like them. Turnaround time was his biggest complaint. It sometimes took nearly 2 weeks between sending one back and getting the next, so that is something to consider. It can get awfully expensive buying games just to try them out. Have you ever traded games in? There is a Gamestop out by Wally World in Russellville that Andrew likes to visit when we are down there. They give store credit for games traded in. Guess thats better than them just sitting on a shelf! HTH Donna